论文标题

在地区选举中说服选民

Persuading Voters in District-based Elections

论文作者

Castiglioni, Matteo, Gatti, Nicola

论文摘要

我们专注于代理商可以利用其信息优势来操纵选举结果的情况。特别是,我们与两名候选人一起研究基于地区的选举,其中选举的获胜者是赢得大多数地区的候选人。基于地区的选举是在全球范围内(例如,英国和美国)的,并且是广泛研究的投票机制的自然延伸(例如,K-Voting和多元化投票)。我们诉诸于贝叶斯说服框架,在该框架中,操纵者(发送者)在战略上向选民(接收者)策略性地披露了他们的信念。我们研究了两个私人信号,在该信号传导中,发件人可以使用每个接收器的私人通信渠道和公共信号传导,在该通信中,发件人可以为所有接收器使用单个通信渠道。此外,我们首次介绍了半公开信号传导,在该信号中,发件人可以每个地区使用一个通信渠道。我们表明,私人和(半)公共信号之间存在明显的区别。特别是,最佳的私人信号计划可以比(半)公共胜利的概率任意更好,并且可以有效地计算,而最佳(半)公共信号方案在多项式时间内都不能近似于任何因素,除非p = np。但是,我们表明,合理的放松允许设计多标准PTASS,以实现最佳(半)公共信号方案。在此过程中,我们引入了一种新颖的属性,即比较稳定性,并在总体贝叶斯说服问题中为公共信号传导设计了双标准PTA,而当发送者的效用函数与国家依赖性相关时。

We focus on the scenario in which an agent can exploit his information advantage to manipulate the outcome of an election. In particular, we study district-based elections with two candidates, in which the winner of the election is the candidate that wins in the majority of the districts. District-based elections are adopted worldwide (e.g., UK and USA) and are a natural extension of widely studied voting mechanisms (e.g., k-voting and plurality voting). We resort to the Bayesian persuasion framework, where the manipulator (sender) strategically discloses information to the voters (receivers) that update their beliefs rationally. We study both private signaling, in which the sender can use a private communication channel per receiver, and public signaling, in which the sender can use a single communication channel for all the receivers. Furthermore, for the first time, we introduce semi-public signaling in which the sender can use a single communication channel per district. We show that there is a sharp distinction between private and (semi-)public signaling. In particular, optimal private signaling schemes can provide an arbitrarily better probability of victory than (semi-)public ones and can be computed efficiently, while optimal (semi-)public signaling schemes cannot be approximated to within any factor in polynomial time unless P=NP. However, we show that reasonable relaxations allow the design of multi-criteria PTASs for optimal (semi-)public signaling schemes. In doing so, we introduce a novel property, namely comparative stability, and we design a bi-criteria PTAS for public signaling in general Bayesian persuasion problems beyond elections when the sender's utility function is state-dependent.

扫码加入交流群

加入微信交流群

微信交流群二维码

扫码加入学术交流群,获取更多资源