论文标题
“距离很重要”的悖论:促进团队内协作可能会损害团队间的协作
A "Distance Matters" Paradox: Facilitating Intra-Team Collaboration Can Harm Inter-Team Collaboration
论文作者
论文摘要
通过确定团队有效远程工作所需的社会技术条件,自2000年推出以来,距离事项框架在CSCW中一直具有影响力。此后,协作技术和实践的进步使团队越来越接近实现这些条件。本文在一个偏远的组织中提出了十个月的民族志,我们观察到,尽管表现出了出色的远程合作,但团队在跨团队边界进行了自相矛盾的努力。我们扩展了距离事务框架以说明团队间的协作,认为挑战类似于原始团队内部框架中的框架(共同基础,协作准备,协作技术准备和工作耦合) - 但在团体间量表上的实现方式持续了不同。 Finally, we identify a fundamental tension between the intra- and inter-team layers: the collaboration technology and practices that help individual teams thrive (e.g., adopting customized collaboration software) can also prompt collaboration challenges in the inter-team layer, and conversely the technology and practices that facilitate inter-team collaboration (e.g., strong centralized IT organizations) can harm practices at the intra-team layer.在距离方面增加团队间层的框架为CSCW打开了新的机会,在此过程中,平衡团队和组织协作需求之间的紧张关系将是未来几十年来远程工作的重要技术,运营和组织挑战。
By identifying the socio-technical conditions required for teams to work effectively remotely, the Distance Matters framework has been influential in CSCW since its introduction in 2000. Advances in collaboration technology and practices have since brought teams increasingly closer to achieving these conditions. This paper presents a ten-month ethnography in a remote organization, where we observed that despite exhibiting excellent remote collaboration, teams paradoxically struggled to collaborate across team boundaries. We extend the Distance Matters framework to account for inter-team collaboration, arguing that challenges analogous to those in the original intra-team framework -- common ground, collaboration readiness, collaboration technology readiness, and coupling of work -- persist but are actualized differently at the inter-team scale. Finally, we identify a fundamental tension between the intra- and inter-team layers: the collaboration technology and practices that help individual teams thrive (e.g., adopting customized collaboration software) can also prompt collaboration challenges in the inter-team layer, and conversely the technology and practices that facilitate inter-team collaboration (e.g., strong centralized IT organizations) can harm practices at the intra-team layer. The addition of the inter-team layer to the Distance Matters framework opens new opportunities for CSCW, where balancing the tension between team and organizational collaboration needs will be a critical technological, operational, and organizational challenge for remote work in the coming decades.